Windows 10 Licensing Logic


Written by David Cattanach on July 13th 2015

Is Windows 10 going to be free? Will Windows 10 be the last ever version? Will 2015 be a great summer? Well, let's tackle the second question here.

Never Pay for Windows Again for the Same Device (Home and Pro editions)

Currently, you might buy a PC and it will come with Windows pre-installed. You've paid for the OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) licence of Windows. You'll get feature updates and security patches from time to time and you can choose to install them or hide them. It's up to you or you organisation's IT policy.

With Windows 10, you won't have a choice. Windows updates will be applied when they're ready. So in a way, Windows 10 will be the last version because you will never have to pay for the next version of the client OS on the same PC; new features will just be installed. If you need to buy a new machine, you'll pay for the OEM licences part of the PC's purchase price and then Windows will just be kept up to date for the lifetime of the device.

You may be concentrating on the negative here that updates will be automatically installed. Think about three huge positives though:

  1. You never need to pay for Windows again on the same machine and you'll always have the latest version
  2. No more wipe and reload upgrades
  3. Software vendors and developers can almost guarantee that 90% of Windows users will have the same build

The third point there should make you smile if your PC has ever crashed or you've needed to phone support because an application isn't working. There are so many combinations of OS, patches, drivers, runtime files and versions around that reliability and consistency are devilishly hard to achieve. Applications and peripherals should work far better if the manufacturers and developers can work to a stable and single platform.

Windows Enterprise and Windows Education edition customers will be required to maintain their Software Assurance (SA) in order to enjoy new feature updates. So we have a subtlety here; whilst enterprise customers will not need to pay for the Windows licence again on the same device, they will need to maintain their SA annuity. We’ll explain why in the last section of this post.

Why is Windows Becoming a Service?

The world of software is changing to cloud – a.k.a software as a service. With that change comes different release cadences. If you've been in IT for a while you'll be familiar with the terms 3.5 inch floppy, modem and three-year release cycles. Office 365 has a monthly release cadence. Azure enjoys weekly updates. This is the way of the world; goodbye versions and hello evergreen services. Innovation has become faster and users expect new features quicker.

What if I Don't Want to Automatically Install Updates?

Windows 10 is going to have three broad demarcations of users: consumers, business users and mission-critical business systems. For each type there is something known as a 'branch'.

Consumers will be subject to the Current Branch (CB) and will receive Windows updates as they are released. Of course, they will have gone through extensive testing via engineering builds, internal testing, early adopters and the Windows Insider program beforehand so several millions of users will already have installed these updates.

Business Users will default to Current Branch but have the option to select Current Branch for Business (CBB). This allows them to defer feature updates for up to eight months after they're released to the Current Branch. This provides ample time for testing, compatibility work and fixes and just to wait and see how the hundreds of millions of Current Branch users get on with the updates. The updates can be deferred but they will need to be installed within that eight-month time-frame. Organisations will be able to control and manage how updates (including critical and security updates) are deployed using tools such as System Centre Configuration Manager, Windows Server Update Services or a new Windows 10 service called Windows Update for Business.

PCs running life-dependent, highly secure or mission-critical systems, for example in a life-support centre or a military aerospace controller etc. have the option to deploy point-in-time releases known as Long Term Service Branch (LTSB). These will not be updated with new features but will have security and critical updates applied, although the organisation can manage and control the distribution of these updates. LTSB releases will be supported for at least 5 years (10 years if the customer has software assurance). New LTSB releases will be made available every two-three years and customers will have the option whether to install them or not.

In short, if you don't want to receive Windows OS updates, you will need to be on the LTSB and that requires certain Windows editions.

Long Term Service Branch is only Available for Windows Enterprise edition

Windows Home edition must be on Current Branch. Windows Pro can be on either Current Branch or Current Branch for Business. This means that both of these editions will be evergreen (CBB allows the updates to be deferred but only for up to 8 months).

Windows Enterprise edition is available with or without software assurance. Windows Enterprise without SA allows the customer to deploy a point-in-time LTSB release, or previous ones (downgrade rights in other words) and for that release to still be supported for 5 years. Windows Enterprise edition with SA also gives customers the rights to new LTSB release when they become available (every 2-3 years). They can choose whether to install new releases or not. SA also means the customer gains extended support so their chosen release will be supported for 10 years.

Even if a customer does have LTSB requirements, it’s unlikely that all of their devices will require it so customers with Windows Enterprise with SA (or indeed Windows Education with SA) will be able to mix Current Branch, CBB and LTSB according to their needs.

One important point to note is that Enterprise edition without SA will not enjoy updates on Current Branch either. Customers with Home and Pro editions will always get the latest features for the life of the device. Enterprise edition without SA will not. The release that's installed will eventually become out of date and the customer will need to buy a licence again to update.

Windows 10 Enterprise Edition with SA is available through all Microsoft Volume Licensing Programs (Open, Open Value, Select+, MPSA, EA, etc.). You can visit this blog post to read about how to upgrade to Windows 10.

Resources

Update


Still have some questions? Check out David's Licensing Logic: Windows 10 FAQ

Comments (20)

  1. Does Reimaging Rights also apply to Windows 10 Professional? I've a customer using desktop licensed with both Windows 7 and Windows 8.1. Can I upgrade these machine and reimage them at a later time?

  2. David Cattanach says:

    Great question Peter. The short answer is yes, subject to some rules and assumptions. The main rule being the specific device you want to reimage is already licenced for Windows 10 Pro when you reimage it. When I say already licenced, this can be via the
    free upgrade offer so if those machines take advantage of the free upgrade offer, it will be possible to reimage them in the future even after the free upgrade period has expired.

    There are assumptions of course. Firstly the Microsoft Product Terms document hasn't yet been updated for Windows 10 so we are assuming rights will be consistent with Windows 8.1. Secondly, we don't know the exact terms and limitations of the Windows 10 upgrade
    offer licence or media because it hasn't been released yet.

    For a fuller explanation, see our article on Reimaging Windows 10
    https://www.imageframe.co.uk/reimaging-windows-10

  3. Peter Selch Dahl | ProActive A/S says:

    Thanks for clarifying!

  4. Thanks for the clarification

  5. Nick Watt says:

    Is there going to be a windows 10 disc/ISO? Example being hard drive failed on my wife's laptop recently. So new hard drive and windows 7 disc to reinstall. What happens once windows 10 is on? Would be counter productive to install from windows 7 disc
    then upgrade it. More sense would be to install straight to 10.

  6. Peter A says:

    How will this work with upgrading PCs though? Ram upgrade, faulty MB or CPU?

  7. Joe Bosak says:

    I have a few questions:

    1. How will licensing work for people who build their own PC and would normally buy a retail version of Windows? Is that licence going to be transferable to a subsequent build, or is the retail licence going to be limited to that particular PC [and if so, what's
    the definition of "that particular PC"]?

    2. How is the lifespan of a PC going to be determined? If I have a PC with Windows now, will it still be supported as long as the hardware is still operational, or is there going to be a time limit? Or just a drift towards bits of hardware no longer being supported
    which would result in being forced to upgrade to a newer PC [and a new Windows licence]? Not everyone cares about the latest capabilities – plenty of people only use PCs to browse the web.

  8. Anonymous says:

    Today’s the day, Windows 10 has arrived!

  9. Simon Jackson says:

    Thanks for the article. My question probably has a slight overlap with a previous question:

    Current versions of Windows rely upon product/license keys to validate an install, gained from either a product license sticker (or baked into the BIOS). How will Windows 10 handle this, especially for machines upgraded for free from 7 or 8.1? If I want/need
    to reinstall Windows 10 (on an upgraded machine), how will this be achieved?

    Similarly, if I have a business with – say – 20 PCs running Windows 7 Pro, how do I get the free upgrade to 10 for them all, without the company network downloading 10's of GB of updates. I want to just image a machine and then deploy via WDS… but, again,
    how is the licensing managed?

    Please help! I'm really struggling to get an answer to these questions. Thanks!

  10. JohnL says:

    So does one of the options allow the equivalent option of "download and notify" updates, as if I leave my machine serving some files overnight I don't want it rebooting in the middle of some person a few time-zones away downloading something?

    Also there have been a lot of BSOD updates over the years (mostly for a small, but varying, subset of users), will they automatically install on consumer's machines then re-install again if removed?

  11. Brian Grainger says:

    1) Is it possible to run Windows 10 Home without being connected to the Internet all the time? I realise you need to be connected for updates but what about just doing work – possibly at a location without an Internet connection.

  12. courtney jarvis says:

    What happens if you upgrade your pc , so time later it requires a rebuild for one reason or another . What will be the process. Will you have to rebuild with a old O/S first, and then hope the Windows 10 upgrade at some point? Or will an ISO be available
    so that it could be burnt to a disk?

  13. courtney jarvis says:

    What happens if you upgrade your pc , so time later it requires a rebuild for one reason or another . What will be the process. Will you have to rebuild with a old O/S first, and then hope the Windows 10 upgrade at some point? Or will an ISO be available
    so that it could be burnt to a disk?

  14. Harry Eagles says:

    Brian – It is still possible to use a Windows 10 device whilst not connected to the internet

  15. Harry Eagles says:

    We have had a number of questions related to Windows 10 (not merely licensing related) and are working to create a Q&A article in which we attempt to answer as many of these queries as possible

  16. Harry Eagles says:

    The answers to many of your Windows 10 questions can be found on the Windows 10 FAQ & Tips here:
    https://www.microsoft.com/en-US/windows/windows-10-faq?WT

  17. Anonymous says:

    Windows 10 was released on the 29 th July and was made available in volume licensing on the 1 st August. After a great deal of audience interaction on the recent Windows 10 Licensing Logic article, it seemed like a good time to revisit some questions

  18. Anonymous says:

    Part of the Microsoft Licensing Logic series from the Microsoft Licensing team. Just when you think Microsoft

  19. Anonymous says:

    2015 has been one of the best years for the TechNet UK Blog; here’s 10 of the most popular articles as chosen (more or less) by you!

  20. Paul Brossoit says:

    Just want to make sure i’m getting this Windows 10 Pro available updates. If a client keeps his system for 6 years because he purchased a very high end system, he wont have access to updates after 5 years?

    Thanks,
    Paul