SOA vs Web 2.0 continued


 

Well the discussion around Web 2.0 and SOA certainly heated up last week. Dion sent me this interesting synopsis:


 


Edge Perspectives with John Hagel: SOA Versus Web 2.0?



Rough Type: Nicholas Carr’s Blog: The web services schism



EarlyStageVC: Web 2.0 – Now What?


» When the worlds of SOA and Web 2.0 collide | Enterprise Web 2.0 | ZDNet.com



» Hagel: Use Web 2.0 to break the SOA logjam | Service-Oriented Architecture | ZDNet.com


SOA is Dead, Long Live Web 2.0 | Venture Chronicles



SOA Versus Web 2.0? | Venture Chronicles



Rough Type: Nicholas Carr’s Blog: Web 2.0’s numbskull factor



Dave Orchard’s Blog: SOA vs Web 2.0: manufacturing a controversy



Microsoft and Enterprise 2.0 | Veryard Projects – Innovation for Demanding Change



Web 2.0 meets the enterprise | Tech News on ZDNet


The discusion thead on Memeorandum, with more links: http://tech.memeorandum.com/060427/p5#a060427p5


 And then this week Phil, another spark alumni, hotted things up with his blog “SOA at rock bottom”


So what do I think? Lets just say that I sent this picture of me around to the group.


Comments (6)

  1. neilwd says:

    Argh.

    Mike, please tell me you know that this should all be taken with a pinch of salt.

    This is all from the heart of the blogsphere echochamber (or should that be egochamber)?

    One example: check out the references cited in Phil Wainewright’s piece. All thinkers, all bloggers – but how many are really in touch with what’s going on out there in business?

    We’re just kicking off some primary research – yes, that’s asking *real people* – what they’re doing with SOA and how they feel about it. I will believe that – not a load of me-too "analysis" from people with Gartner’s hype curve stuck on the wall above their desks.

  2. Michael Platt says:

    Hi Neil

    Yes, I realise that this is all thinkers rather than doers so I have sent the last couple of weeks talking to real companies about what they are doing in the Web 2.0 space and have come back with some amazing stories and insights. I will be blogging more on these in future but suffice to say I belive that neither the SOA mechants or the blogsphere have it completely right. I’m not sure I do yet either but we are certainly in for interesting time!

  3. neilwd says:

    Sounds interesting! I think you’re at WAX in London next week so I’ll learn more about it there! – Neil

    [PS thanks for the link in your previous entry…]